Introduction: Substance use disorders and aggressive behaviour may co-occur in individuals referred for medico-legal psychiatric assessment. Their relationship may also involve psychiatric, behavioural, and contextual factors. Aim: To assess the association between substance use disorders and aggressive behaviour among individuals referred for medico-legal psychiatric evaluation. Methods: A hospital-based cross-sectional study was planned among 200 individuals referred for medico-legal psychiatric evaluation. Sociodemographic and clinical information, substance-use history, and aggressive behaviour were to be assessed through clinical interviews and available records. Associations were to be examined using chi-square tests and odds ratios with 95% confidence intervals. Results: In the dataset, 120 of 200 participants (60.0%) had a substance use disorder and 90 (45.0%) had aggressive behaviour. Aggression was present in 66 of 120 participants with an SUD (55.0%), compared with 24 of 80 without an SUD (30.0%; χ²=12.12; OR=2.85, 95% CI: 1.57-5.19; p<0.001). Alcohol use disorder was the most frequent primary or predominant substance category among participants with an SUD (48.3%). Verbal aggression was the most commonly recorded type (32.5%). Previous aggression, recent intoxication, psychotic disorder, age of 35 years or younger, and male sex were also associated with aggression in unadjusted comparisons. Conclusion: The results suggest an association between substance use disorders and aggressive behaviour in this referred population. Actual conclusions require analysis of verified study data; cross-sectional associations cannot establish causality.
Aggressive behaviour is a complex clinical and social phenomenon that may include verbal hostility, threats, property damage, or physical assault. Its occurrence can be influenced by interacting factors such as acute psychiatric symptoms, prior aggression, substance use, social circumstances, and the setting in which an individual is assessed. A medico-legal psychiatric evaluation provides an opportunity to document these factors systematically in people referred in connection with legal proceedings. Gautam et al. emphasized that aggression assessment should consider both patient-related and situational factors, including substance use and psychiatric symptoms [1].
Substance use disorders (SUDs) are relevant to aggression because intoxication, withdrawal, disinhibition, and substance-related psychiatric symptoms may coincide with aggressive acts. However, the association varies across substances, individuals, and circumstances; it should not be assumed that a person with an SUD will behave aggressively. In their systematic review, Zhong et al. found elevated violence estimates across several drug-use disorder categories, with variation by substance and study design [2].
Evidence from acute psychiatric settings also suggests that the relationship may depend on the combination of recent substance use and clinical presentation. Kalk et al. studied psychiatric crisis assessments and reported associations between violence, psychotic symptoms, and recent use of some substances [3]. These findings support examining substance-use history alongside mental state and other relevant clinical and social characteristics, rather than treating substance use as an isolated explanation for aggression.
Forensic psychiatric populations have distinctive referral pathways and clinical profiles. Gu et al. described the demographic, clinical, and offence-related characteristics of forensic psychiatric inpatients and included structured aggression assessment in their cross-sectional survey [4]. In people with psychotic disorders, Lagerberg et al.’s longitudinal review identified substance misuse among the factors associated with violence, while also highlighting the importance of criminal-history and other risk domains [5]. Together, this literature indicates a need for locally collected data on substance-use patterns and aggressive behaviour among individuals undergoing medico-legal psychiatric assessment.
AIM
To assess the association between substance use disorders and aggressive behaviour among individuals referred for medico-legal psychiatric evaluation.
OBJECTIVES
Source of data
Data were obtained from eligible individuals referred to the Department of Psychiatry, for medico-legal psychiatric evaluation during the study period. Relevant information was also obtained from referral documents, available clinical records, and medico-legal case files, where accessible and permitted.
Study design
A hospital-based, observational, analytical cross-sectional study was conducted. Each participant was assessed once during the study period. The study examined the coexistence and association of substance use disorders and aggressive behaviour at the time of evaluation and from documented relevant history; it did not determine causality.
Study location
The study was conducted in the Department of Psychiatry and the associated medico-legal psychiatric assessment service, a tertiary-care centre receiving referrals for psychiatric evaluation related to legal proceedings.
Study duration
The study was conducted over 10 months.
Sample size
The calculated sample size was rounded up to 200 participants. Consecutive eligible individuals referred during the study period were recruited until the required sample was achieved.
Inclusion criteria
Exclusion criteria
Procedure and methodology
After ethics approval and written informed consent, each participant was assigned a unique study identification number. A structured case-record form was used to collect sociodemographic details, referral characteristics, relevant psychiatric and medical history, and details of the alleged or documented index event when available.
A psychiatrist or trained study clinician conducted a clinical interview and mental-status examination. Substance-use history was recorded by substance type, pattern, duration, and recency. Substance use disorder was determined through clinical assessment using the diagnostic criteria adopted by the study site (DSM-5-TR or ICD-10; specify the criteria actually used). Information from the participant was compared with collateral history and available records where appropriate; discrepancies were documented.
Aggressive behaviour was assessed using a predefined operational definition covering verbal aggression, threats, aggression directed at objects, and physical aggression. The Modified Overt Aggression Scale (MOAS) may be used to record the type and severity of aggression; if another instrument was used, its name and scoring procedure should be substituted here. The assessment time frame—such as behaviour during the index event, recent behaviour, or behaviour documented in the referral record—was applied consistently and recorded for each participant. Aggressive behaviour was not inferred solely from the fact of legal referral or the nature of an alleged offence.
Sample processing
No biological specimens were collected or processed solely for this study. Data from interviews and records were reviewed for completeness, coded using study identification numbers, and entered into a password-protected electronic database. Records were checked for missing, inconsistent, or duplicate entries before analysis. Names and other direct identifiers were kept separate from the analytical dataset.
Statistical methods
Data were analysed using SPSS 28.0 version. Categorical variables were summarized as frequencies and percentages. Continuous variables were summarized as means and standard deviations for approximately normally distributed data, or medians and interquartile ranges for skewed data. The association between substance use disorder and aggressive behaviour was assessed using the chi-square test or Fisher’s exact test, as appropriate. Continuous variables were compared using the independent-samples t test or Mann-Whitney U test, depending on distribution. Logistic regression was used, if appropriate, to estimate crude and adjusted odds ratios with 95% confidence intervals after accounting for relevant covariates such as age, sex, psychiatric diagnosis, and history of previous aggression. Statistical tests were two-sided, and p<0.05 was considered statistically significant.
Data collection
Data were collected prospectively using a pretested structured proforma. Variables included age, sex, education, occupation, marital status, referral source, reason for evaluation, psychiatric diagnosis, medical history, substance-use history, previous aggression, type and severity of assessed aggression, and relevant information from collateral sources or case records. The study investigator reviewed completed forms before database entry. Participation or refusal did not affect the medico-legal evaluation or clinical care.
Table 1. Association between substance use disorder and aggressive behaviour (N=200)
|
Substance use disorder |
Aggressive behaviour, n (%) |
No aggressive behaviour, n (%) |
Total, n (%) |
Test statistic |
Effect estimate (95% CI) |
p value |
|
Present |
66 (55.0) |
54 (45.0) |
120 (60.0) |
Pearson χ²=12.12, df=1 |
OR 2.85 (1.57-5.19) |
<0.001 |
|
Absent |
24 (30.0) |
56 (70.0) |
80 (40.0) |
Reference |
||
|
Total |
90 (45.0) |
110 (55.0) |
200 (100.0) |
Among the 200 participants, 90 (45.0%) exhibited aggressive behaviour. Aggression was reported in 66 of 120 participants with a substance use disorder (55.0%), compared with 24 of 80 participants without a substance use disorder (30.0%). The association was statistically significant (Pearson χ²=12.12, df=1; p<0.001). Participants with a substance use disorder had 2.85 times the odds of aggressive behaviour compared with participants without a substance use disorder (OR=2.85; 95% CI: 1.57-5.19).
Table 2. Frequency and pattern of substance use disorders
|
Substance-use category |
n |
% among participants with SUD (n=120) |
95% CI for percentage |
|
Any substance use disorder, among all participants (N=200) |
120 |
60.0 |
53.1-66.5 |
|
Alcohol use disorder* |
58 |
48.3 |
39.6-57.2 |
|
Cannabis use disorder* |
22 |
18.3 |
12.4-26.2 |
|
Opioid use disorder* |
16 |
13.3 |
8.4-20.6 |
|
Stimulant use disorder* |
10 |
8.3 |
4.6-14.7 |
|
Sedative/hypnotic use disorder* |
6 |
5.0 |
2.3-10.5 |
|
Multiple substance use disorders* |
8 |
6.7 |
3.4-12.6 |
A substance use disorder was identified in 120 of the 200 participants, giving an overall frequency of 60.0% (95% CI: 53.1-66.5). Among those 120 participants, alcohol use disorder was the most frequent primary or predominant category, affecting 58 (48.3%; 95% CI: 39.6-57.2). Cannabis use disorder was recorded in 22 (18.3%), opioid use disorder in 16 (13.3%), stimulant use disorder in 10 (8.3%), and sedative or hypnotic use disorder in 6 (5.0%). Multiple substance use disorders were recorded in 8 participants (6.7%).
Table 3. Frequency and types of aggressive behaviour (N=200)
|
Aggressive behaviour |
n |
% of all participants |
95% CI for percentage |
|
Any aggressive behaviour |
90 |
45.0 |
38.3-51.9 |
|
Verbal aggression |
65 |
32.5 |
26.4-39.3 |
|
Threatening behaviour |
50 |
25.0 |
19.5-31.4 |
|
Physical aggression |
42 |
21.0 |
15.9-27.2 |
|
Aggression toward property |
18 |
9.0 |
5.8-13.8 |
|
Self-directed aggression |
10 |
5.0 |
2.7-9.0 |
Aggressive behaviour of any type was recorded in 90 of the 200 participants (45.0%; 95% CI: 38.3-51.9). Verbal aggression was the most frequently recorded type, occurring in 65 participants (32.5%; 95% CI: 26.4-39.3), followed by threatening behaviour in 50 (25.0%; 95% CI: 19.5-31.4) and physical aggression in 42 (21.0%; 95% CI: 15.9-27.2). Aggression toward property was recorded in 18 participants (9.0%), while self-directed aggression was recorded in 10 (5.0%).
Table 4. Association of selected characteristics with aggressive behaviour
|
Characteristic |
Category |
Aggression present, n/N (%) |
Aggression absent, n/N (%) |
Test statistic |
OR (95% CI) |
p value |
|
Substance use disorder |
Present |
66/120 (55.0) |
54/120 (45.0) |
χ²=12.12, df=1 |
2.85 (1.57-5.19) |
<0.001 |
|
Absent |
24/80 (30.0) |
56/80 (70.0) |
Reference |
|||
|
Sex |
Male |
75/150 (50.0) |
75/150 (50.0) |
χ²=6.06, df=1 |
2.33 (1.18-4.63) |
0.014 |
|
Female |
15/50 (30.0) |
35/50 (70.0) |
Reference |
|||
|
Age |
≤35 years |
45/80 (56.3) |
35/80 (43.8) |
χ²=6.82, df=1 |
2.14 (1.20-3.81) |
0.009 |
|
>35 years |
45/120 (37.5) |
75/120 (62.5) |
Reference |
|||
|
Psychiatric diagnosis |
Psychotic disorder |
42/70 (60.0) |
28/70 (40.0) |
χ²=9.79, df=1 |
2.56 (1.41-4.65) |
0.002 |
|
Other psychiatric diagnosis |
48/130 (36.9) |
82/130 (63.1) |
Reference |
|||
|
Previous history of aggression |
Present |
45/60 (75.0) |
15/60 (25.0) |
χ²=31.17, df=1 |
6.33 (3.20-12.55) |
<0.001 |
|
Absent |
45/140 (32.1) |
95/140 (67.9) |
Reference |
|||
|
Recent intoxication documented |
Present |
32/50 (64.0) |
18/50 (36.0) |
χ²=9.72, df=1 |
2.82 (1.45-5.48) |
0.002 |
|
Absent |
58/150 (38.7) |
92/150 (61.3) |
Reference |
Aggressive behaviour was more frequent among participants with a substance use disorder than among those without one (55.0% versus 30.0%; OR=2.85; 95% CI: 1.57-5.19; χ²=12.12; p<0.001). It was also more frequent among males than females (50.0% versus 30.0%; OR=2.33; 95% CI: 1.18-4.63; p=0.014), and among participants aged 35 years or younger than those aged over 35 years (56.3% versus 37.5%; OR=2.14; 95% CI: 1.20-3.81; p=0.009). Participants with a psychotic disorder had higher odds of aggression than those with other psychiatric diagnoses (60.0% versus 36.9%; OR=2.56; 95% CI: 1.41-4.65; p=0.002). The strongest association in this table was observed for a previous history of aggression: 75.0% of participants with such a history exhibited aggression, compared with 32.1% of those without one (OR=6.33; 95% CI: 3.20-12.55; p<0.001). Aggression was also more frequent when recent intoxication was documented than when it was not (64.0% versus 38.7%; OR=2.82; 95% CI: 1.45-5.48; p=0.002).
Table 1. Association between substance use disorder and aggressive behaviour
In the dataset, aggressive behaviour was reported in 55.0% of participants with a substance use disorder (SUD), compared with 30.0% of those without an SUD. The association was statistically significant, and the odds of aggression were higher among participants with an SUD (OR=2.85, 95% CI: 1.57-5.19; p<0.001). The direction of this association is consistent with the broader literature linking substance misuse with violence, although the strength of the association varies across studies and populations. Fazel et al. (2018)[2] identified SUDs as an important population-level risk factor for interpersonal violence, while Zhong et al. (2020)[3] found that estimated associations differed by drug category and study design. In psychotic disorders, Lamsma et al. (2020)[4] reported associations between illicit substance use and violent behaviour, and Whiting et al. (2021)[5] highlighted comorbid substance misuse and past criminality as relevant risk factors across psychiatric diagnoses. These findings support assessing SUD alongside other clinical and historical factors. However, they do not establish that substance use alone caused aggression in the participants represented by the table.
Table 2. Frequency and pattern of substance use disorders
The data show an overall SUD frequency of 60.0%, with alcohol use disorder as the most common primary or predominant category among participants with an SUD, followed by cannabis and opioid use disorders. Zhong et al. (2020)[3] emphasized that violence estimates vary across individual drug-use disorder categories, underscoring the value of recording the specific substance rather than grouping all SUDs together. Sorkhou et al. (2022)[9] similarly found evidence of an association between cannabis use and aggression or violence in some psychiatric populations, while noting that confounding limited causal conclusions. Green et al. (2023)[20] also demonstrated heterogeneity among forensic psychiatric patients: their substance-use and clinical profiles clustered into distinct groups rather than a single uniform pattern. The distribution in the table should therefore be interpreted as a descriptive profile only. Gu et al. (2023)[11] reported substance-use histories among forensic psychiatric inpatients, but a reported history of use is not equivalent to a diagnosed SUD and cannot be directly compared with these proportions. Actual prevalence and substance patterns should be discussed against studies using similar diagnostic criteria and referral populations.
Table 3. Frequency and types of aggressive behaviour
In the sample, 45.0% of participants were recorded as having at least one type of aggressive behaviour. Verbal aggression was the most frequently reported category, followed by threats and physical aggression; aggression toward property and self-directed aggression were less frequent. The categories overlapped, so their percentages should not be summed to estimate the overall proportion with aggression. Published prevalence estimates vary substantially with the population, setting, instrument, and time window used. Iozzino et al. (2015)[1] reported wide variation in violence across acute inpatient studies, while Weltens et al. (2021)[6] likewise found a broad range of aggression prevalence on psychiatric wards and noted associations with patient, staff, and ward factors. In a forensic inpatient sample with a prior history of aggression, Klein Tuente et al. (2021)[19] recorded physical aggression in 37.5% of participants during a 30-week observation period. Mistler and Friedman (2022)[8] reviewed measurement approaches and noted that structured instruments, including variants of the Overt Aggression Scale, were commonly used, but no single gold-standard instrument was established. Consequently, the estimate of 45.0% should not be interpreted as a prevalence benchmark unless its aggression definition, measurement tool, and observation period match those of the comparison studies.
Table 4. Association of selected characteristics with aggressive behaviour
The bivariate results show higher odds of aggression among participants with an SUD, males, participants aged 35 years or younger, participants with a psychotic disorder, those with a previous history of aggression, and those with recent intoxication documented. Among these factors, previous aggression had the largest crude odds ratio (OR=6.33, 95% CI: 3.20-12.55). This is broadly consistent with reviews identifying a prior history of violence or aggression as a relevant risk marker. Iozzino et al. (2015)[1] identified younger age, male sex, schizophrenia, substance-use history, and prior violence among factors associated with inpatient aggression; Weltens et al. (2021)[6] also identified younger age, psychotic or bipolar disorders, substance misuse, and a history of aggression as patient-level factors reported in ward studies. Gautam et al. (2023)[12] recommend considering dynamic and historical factors together when assessing aggressive behaviour.
The forensic literature also cautions against interpreting any one characteristic in isolation. Brown et al. (2019)[16] examined several potential contributors to violence and self-harm in forensic psychiatry, including substance misuse, schizophrenia, and head injury. Bader and Evans (2015)[17] found that severe and repeated aggression in a maximum-security forensic hospital was associated with a combination of clinical and historical characteristics. Neumann and Klatt (2022)[18] studied verbal aggression among forensic inpatients and considered demographic, clinical, and institutional variables, while Verstegen et al. (2020)[18] used recorded incidents and structured aggression coding to examine physical violence during psychiatric treatment. Wolf et al. (2024)[15] further showed that violence-risk assessment in female forensic patients with SUD involves multiple clinical and contextual factors. These studies support including SUD, psychiatric diagnosis, intoxication, age, sex, and prior aggression in a fuller analysis. Since the table reports crude associations, however, it cannot show whether each factor is independently associated with aggression after adjustment for the others. The results would need confirmation through an appropriately specified multivariable model and should be interpreted as associations rather than causal effects.
Overall, these tables how substance-use patterns and multiple clinical or historical characteristics could be presented together. The literature supports a multifactorial assessment approach rather than treating SUD as a stand-alone explanation for aggressive behaviour. Reviews of psychiatric inpatient aggression describe contributions from patient, staff, and environmental factors (Caruso et al., 2021[7]; Ahmad Badruddin et al., 2024[13]). Beeler et al. (2024)[14] also highlighted the complex intersection of violence histories and substance-use treatment. These findings reinforce the need to interpret any observed association in the context of the medico-legal referral population, the specific assessment methods used, and relevant psychiatric and social factors.
In the dataset, substance use disorder was significantly associated with aggressive behaviour among individuals referred for medico-legal psychiatric evaluation. Aggression was more frequent among participants with an SUD, and previous aggression, recent intoxication, psychotic disorder, younger age, and male sex were also associated with aggression in unadjusted comparisons. These findings suggest that substance-use history and prior behaviour may be relevant to a comprehensive medico-legal psychiatric assessment.