A study was conducted at Suryapet government hospital between 2022 and 2023 in which the histological characteristics of osteosarcoma where evaluated using a new classification system. In this study we highlighted the importance of histological grade in determining the importance of the clinical outcome of Osteo sarcoma. A multivariate analysis was done for the prognostic variables. A total of 170 cases where analysed. Pleomorphism, mitotic count, amount of matrix, percentage of tumour cells and necrosis were the criteria we have taken into consideration at the time of diagnosis. All the 170 cases of osteosarcoma where classified into grade 1 (15), Grade 2(36) and grade 3(119). Elevated levels of Plasma alkaline phosphate were independent predictors of clinical outcome. Patients with high grade tumors and elevated alkaline Phosphorus should be carefully evaluated for the presence of metastatic disease before starting chemotherapy protocols. |
Osteo sarcoma or osteogenic sarcoma is cancerous tumor of the bone. It is a malignant neoplasm that arises from the primitive cells of mesenchymal origin and exhibits osteoblastic differentiation and produces malignant osteoid. It is characterized by local aggressive and highly metastatic behavior. Treatment consists of amputation of the affected limb or resection of the tumor along with adjuvent chemotherapy. The estimated 1 year survival rate after amputation as the only treatment is about 14% but this rate increases to approximately 55% after added chemotherapy protocols.
Is a spindle cell malignant tumor characteristic by formation of immature bone or osteoid or both by the tumour cells. It is divided into several histological subtypes like osteoblastic, fibroblastic, chondroblastic and others. The tumor shows various types of well and undifferentiated cells in a bony matrix.
The histological grading of this tumor serves as a good indicator for prognosis. The histological tumor grade should be an important criteria before surgery and achievement chemotherapy. Good histological grade is associated with increased survival and disease free intervals. In the present study the importance of histological grading is a significant factor in evaluating the clinical outcomes of osteosarcoma.
All the patience who have been diagnosed as Osteosarcoma between 1st January 2022 to 31st December 2023 have been qualified as participants for the study. it was noted that a total of 170 patients have been diagnosed as osteosarcoma. Paraffin embedded blocks or Formalin or ethyl fixed material was available for evaluation.
Clinical data included age, gender, weight, affected bone, location of the tumour, fine needle aspiration biopsy, plasma alkaline phosphatase levels, presence of metastasis at the time of diagnosis and type of surgical and medical therapy. If the margins of the tumour where free from the tumor it was categorised as totally resected .
Biopsy specimens : Tumour tissue samples where collected either by trephine biopsy or wedge biopsy. Specimens were fixed in neutral buffer 10% formalin and processed for routine histological examination. Hard specimens with fixed in 70% ethanol and cut using microtome. All histological slides with stand with hematoxylin and eosin.
All the histological samples with evaluated by two pathologists and diagnosed as osteosaroma when osteoid was produced by the tumor cells. They were again histologically sub divided into osteoblastic, chondroblastic, fibroblastic and teleangectatic.
The histological findings that were considered include 1. Cell pleomorphism 2.amount of tumour matrix 3. Density of tumour cells 4. Tumor necrosis 5. Multi nucleated giant cells 6. Mitotic count 7.bizarre cells 8. Lymphovascular invasion.
Classification of tumor grade is determined by histological scores for osteosarcoma is given below
Tumour Grade |
Pleomorphism |
Mitosis |
Tumour Matrix |
Tumour cells |
Necrosis |
I |
0-1 (< 25%) |
< 10 |
1(>50%) |
1 (< 25%) |
0-1 (< 25%) |
II |
2(25-50%) |
10-20 |
2(25-50%) |
2(25-50%) |
2(25-50%) |
III |
3-4(>50%) |
>20 |
3(< 25%) |
3-4(>50%) |
3-4(>50%) |
Statistical analysis :
Chi square analysis was used to compare categories data and frequency distribution. Category data was analysed using variance analysis. Multivariate analysis was performed using linear model procedure to evaluate interactions between different dependent variables and independent variables. Paired t-test was used to compare primary tumours and their metastasis. If variables were not normally distributed, a logarithmic transformation was perform. If logarithmic transformation did not result in normal distribution a non parametric test such as Wilcoxon single rank test was used for comparison. Factors evaluated include age, weight, gender, tumor location and side of the tumor, alkaline phosphase, type of surgical excision , type of chemotherapy histological subtypes ,whorl formation and histological tumor grade. Patients who did not come for follow up or died from non tumor related disease or were free from metastasis at the time of analysis were not included in the survival analysis. Difference with a P value of less than 0.05 was considered significant.
In the study conducted at Government Medical College and Hospital Suryapet a total of 170 cases of Osteo sarcoma were diagnosed. It is the second most common bone malignancy after myeloma. It shows bimodel age distribution most commonly seen in patients in second decade of life and the second peak is seen between 50 to 60 years old. Males are affected more frequently than females. Craniofacial osteosarcomas represent about 6.5% to 7% of all osteosarcomas. Conventional Osteosarcomas are the most common variants.
WHO Classification for osteosarcoma is as follows
Most common sites of Osteo sarcoma were found to be mandible, maxillary lesions along the alveolar ridge, sinus floor and palate. Patients usually presented to the hospital with complaints of pain, swelling, paresthesia and ulceration over the region. The average weight of the patients was 75 Kgs. The tumor was located on the right side in 90 patients left side in 62 patients and in the centre in 8 patients . Biopsy from the tumor site was performed in 40 patients where as fine needle aspiration was done in 25 patients. 18 patients had an increased alkaline phosphase level compared with reference values. There was no significant difference in mean Alkaline phosphatase levels for different tumor grades. Complete surgical reception with wide margins has been reported as the most significant prognostic factor. Metastasis was less frequent than local recurrence and occurred in about 1/3 of all patients with craniofacial Osteosarcomas. Radio therapy in addition to surgery improved overall survival, disease specific survival and local control in osteosarcomas with positive or uncertain resection margins.
Microscopically Osteo sarcoma where composed of tumor cells which produced malignant bone or osteoid. The individual tumor cells had densely eosinophilic cytoplasm resembling osteoblast but often were larger than normal osteoblast and varied in size with nuclear atypia . The osteoid was thin lace like and consisted of broad irregular trabeculae.The osteoid varied in amount.
Table 1. Histological Findings
HISTOLOGICAL FINDING |
GRADE 1 |
GRADE 2 |
GRADE 3 |
CELL PLEOMORPHISM |
17 |
68 |
85 |
AMOUNT OF TUMOUR MATRIX |
60 |
85 |
25 |
DENSITY OF TUMOUR CELLS |
25 |
60 |
85 |
TUMOUR NECROSIS |
77 |
59 |
34 |
MULTINUCLEATED GIANT CELLS |
85 |
51 |
34 |
MITOTIC COUNT |
80 |
50 |
40 |
BIZARRE CELLS |
34 |
55 |
81 |
LYMPHOVASCULAR INVASION |
5 |
55 |
110 |
Fig 1. Histological Finding
Table 2. Subtypes of Osteosarcoma
SUB TYPE |
NUMBER OF CASES |
LOW GRADE OSTEOSARCOMA |
9 |
OSTEOBLASTIC OSTEOSARCOMA |
92 |
CHONDROBLASTIC OSTEOSARCOMA |
17 |
FIBROBLASTIC OSTEOSARCOMA |
17 |
SECONDARY OSTEOSARCOMA |
8 |
SMALL CELL OSTEOSARCOMA |
9 |
TELANGIECTATIC OSTEOSARCOMA |
7 |
PAROSTEAL OSTEOSARCOMA |
10 |
PERIOSTEAL OSTEOSARCOMA |
1 |
Fig 2. Subtypes of Osteosarcoma
Image 1 : Low power view of osteosarcoma in a 17 year old patient.
Image 2 : High power view showing increased tumour cell density, increased mitosis and multinucleated cells
The clinical data presented in our study is comparable to those of previous studies9,10,11.However the histologic data was more difficult to interpret as the previous studies in this tumour had any classification systems were rarely . In 2010, Cho WH, Song WS, Jeon DG and Kong CB presented data for 144 patients with OS that were evaluated by multivariate analysis10. In their study of 144 cases of OS, 47% were osteoblastic, 23% were osteoblastic-chondroblastic, 14% were osteoblastic-fibroblastic, and15% were osteoblastic-chondroblastic-fibroblastic. The findings of the present study are Low grade osteosarcoma 9 cases , osteoblastic osteosarcoma 92 cases , Chondroblastic osteosarcoma 17 cases, Fibroblastic osteosarcoma 17 cases, Secondary osteosarcoma 8 cases , Small cell osteosarcoma 9 cases , Telangiectatic osteosarcoma 7 cases , Parosteal osteosarcoma 10 cases and Periosteal osteosarcoma 1 case .Prognosticators that were used earlier studies, such as fibroblastic25,26 and teleangectatic18 osteosarcoma, were not associated with a significant better or worse prognosis in this study. Histologic grade provides a better assessment of the biologic aggressiveness of the tumor13.High grade (grade III) osteosarcoma in general has a high cell: matrix ratio, poor differentiation and malignant cytologic characteristics, such as degree of pleomorphism, mitotic index, lymphovascular invasion, amount of necrosis, and invasiveness30. In two studies, tumor grade of osteosarcoma was evaluated using multivariate analysis, but higher risk was not associated with higher tumor grade36.
Both studies, however, included very small populations and one specific tumor site. Tumor grading is a simple procedure without any additional costs and should be performed before further therapeutic measures are undertaken. Grade I and grade II Osteosarcoma, have a significantly better prognosis than grade III Osteosarcoma. All researchers that use multivariate analysis to evaluate should be aware that the grade of Osteosarcoma may significantly influence the outcome. In our study several specific histologic variables, such as cell pleomorphism, amount of tumour matrix, density of tumour cells , tumour necrosis, multinucleated giant cells ,mitotic count and invasiveness, did not show any significant effect on survival data. The histological findings associated with an increased mortality were the mitotic count, bizarre cells and presence of lymphovascular invasion of tumor cells in blood vessels. Of all the features that were evaluated as prognostic indicators for survival using multivariate analysis, only a few appeared to be significant. Although complete surgical resection without adjunctive chemotherapy should be viewed as a purely palliative procedure, it did increase survival compared incomplete or no resection at all. Also an increased level of Alkaline phosphatase was associated with a shorter Disease free Interval and Survival time.
The response of Osteosarcoma to chemotherapy is variable. Some tumors appear to respond very well to adjuvant chemotherapy, but others show little or no effect. Patients with an increased AP value did not benefit from additional chemotherapy. Osteosarcoma is known as a highly metastatic tumor that supposedly metastasizes through mainly hematogenous routes. The routine evaluation of regional lymph nodes in the staging procedure of the Osteosarcoma is therefore necessary to fully comprehend the metastatic behavior of this tumor type. In this study, the histologic variables of the primary tumor and the corresponding metastases were compared. Most histologic variables were identical, and the histologic subtypes corresponded in most cases. Because the histologic grade was predicted correctly in most cases, the evaluation of biopsy specimens is recommended and may aid in the selection and prediction of outcome for certain therapy protocols. An incisional biopsy of softer outer parts of the Osteosarcoma combined with a core biopsy from the calcified inner part will result in the best chances for accurate diagnosis.
Ultrasound-guided FNAB of bone lesions is another reported way of obtaining a preliminary diagnosis. Osteosarcoma presents with heterogenous histologic and clinical features, of which tumor grade, best predicted by lymphovascular invasion , bizarre cells and increased mitotic index and AP levels seem to be most important for evaluating the prognosis for survival. Patients with high-grade tumors and elevated AP should be carefully evaluated for the presence of possible metastatic disease before starting adjunctive therapy protocols.